Statement Regarding Joan Fitzgerald (D) Voting Record on Key Small Business-Related Issues
My candidacy for Wisconsin State Assembly District 46 on the November 3, 2026 midterm/general election ballot has a unique aspect. My opponent in this election, State Representative Joan Fitzgerald (D), now running for her second term in the state legislature, is also my current state representative - my opponent presently works for me, as well as for us!
Nothing speaks louder than an incumbent’s prior voting record. So, how does my and our Representative Fitzgerald stand on basic issues related to Wisconsin small business – their owners, employees, and their families?
Following is a summary of legislation from the National Federation of Independent Business, and how our incumbent state representative, Joan Fitzgerald, voted on these issues in her first 2-year term of office.
The first two legislative measures listed here are decisive in and of themselves.
Surplus Tax Relief – None for You, Says Joan!
Joan Fitzgerald voted NO. Surplus Tax Relief (May 2026 Special Session - AB 1): VOTED NO to provide over $1 billion in tax relief from the state’s budget surplus in the form of reduced property taxes, direct surplus refund checks, and no tax on tips and overtime. Passed the Assembly 61-32. Failed to pass the Senate 15-18.
Stopping 400-Year Property Tax Increases – We’re Doing It, Says Joan!
Joan Fitzgerald voted NO. Stopping 400-year property tax increases (2025 – SJR 116):
VOTED NO to amend the Wisconsin Constitution to prohibit [watch this double negative] a
governor from using a veto to increase any tax or fee. Passed the Senate 18-15. Passed the
Assembly 54-41. Constitutional Amendment placed on the November 2026 General Election
Ballot.
Joan’s Other NOs on Key Business Issues:
Retail Theft (2025 – AB 89): VOTED NO to close a loophole that allowed repeat criminals to avoid meaningful charges in instances of retail theft. Passed the Senate 27-6. Passed the Assembly 71-26. Signed into law by the governor.
Prohibit Guaranteed Income Programs (2025 – AB 165): VOTED NO to prohibit [watch this double negative] “guaranteed income” programs where individuals can be paid monthly by the government, with little to no requirements. Passed the Senate 18-15. Passed the Assembly 53-42. Vetoed by the governor.
Rights of Nature (2025 – SB 420): VOTED NO to prohibit [watch this double negative] local governments from passing any laws that recognize nature (such as forests and rivers) as legal persons with enforceable rights and protections. Passed the Senate 19-14. Passed the Assembly 54-41. Vetoed by the governor.
Legislative Oversight of Agencies (2025 – AJR 133): VOTED NO to amend the Wisconsin Constitution to reinstate the legislature’s ability to have oversight of state government agencies’ issuance of new rules and regulations. Passed the Senate 18-15. Passed the Assembly 52-45. Enrolled as first consideration of the constitutional amendment.
Sunset of Administrative Rules (2025 – SB 277): VOTED NO to create a sunset date for current administrative code and provides a review process to help reduce regulatory burdens on Wisconsin small businesses. Passed the Senate 18-15. Passed the Assembly 53-45. Vetoed by the governor.
Reduce Costs of Admin Rules (2025 – SB 289): VOTED NO to introduce a net-zero regulatory budgeting framework that requires government agencies, when issuing new regulations that impose costs on businesses, to offset those costs by repealing outdated rules or enacting equivalent cost-reducing regulations. Passed the Senate 18-15. Passed the Assembly 53-45. Vetoed by the governor.
Wheel Tax Vote Required (2025 – SB 467): VOTED NO to require wheel taxes, both new and existing, to be confirmed by voters in a local referendum. Passed the Senate 18-15. Failed to be taken up by the Assembly.
Telehealth (2025 – SB 214): VOTED NO to expand and improves health care services by reducing regulatory burdens and providing accessibility to qualified out-of-state health care providers by allowing professionals that are licensed in another state to provide telehealth services to Wisconsinites. Passed the Senate on Voice Vote. Passed the Assembly 52-44. Vetoed by the governor.
Health Care CHOICE Arrangements (2025 – AB 915): VOTED YES to create health reimbursement arrangements (HRAs) to help small businesses affordably offer health coverage by allowing employers to provide tax-free funds for employees to buy individual plans, providing flexibility while reducing administrative burdens. Passed the Assembly 97-0. Failed to Pass Senate.
LLC Protection (2025 – AB 870): VOTED NO to protect sole proprietors from being replaced by a creditor as the owner of their LLC. Passed the Assembly 58-35. Failed to Pass Senate.
1 National Federation of Independent Business (NFIB) (2025-2026). The voting record for the selected/identified state legislator on key small business issues identified by the NFIB is listed in this Wisconsin Voting Record. Although this Voting Record does not reflect all elements considered by a lawmaker when voting, nor does it represent a complete profile of a legislator, it can be a guide in evaluating the legislator’s attitudes toward small business.
What Will I Do Differently as Your Representative for Wisconsin Assembly District 46?
Joan Fitzgerald’s voting record - my state representative’s voting record – is dismal on tax and key small business issues. But how would I do differently on your behalf as representative to Assembly District 46 after the November 3rd election?
Surplus Refund
Let’s start with the state surplus which is linked to affordability – first item in the list above. Let’s get one thing crystal clear: it’s our money, not the state’s. The ONLY reason the state now has a $3.307 billion surplus is because we paid it in the form of taxes and fees. It’s our money. And in May, the legislature decided to sit on it while you and I struggle with the family budget.
I will work tirelessly on issues related to affordability. This includes – among other key issues and initiatives – refunding our state fiscal surplus back to the people who paid into that surplus. This includes initiatives to reduce future taxes and fees.
I will also be consistent in my legislative initiatives and will take whatever time and effort is necessary to know the “nuts and bolts” of the issues that you, the voters, expect me to know and act upon in your interest.
That mindset, dear voters, comes in part from academic discipline – master’s degrees in Development Economics, Social Work (MSW), and Public Administration (MPA). It also comes from military discipline (27 years, Army Judge Advocate General’s Corps). It also emerges from experience in civic affairs and just plain common sense.
On Joan Fitzgerald’s Decision in May to NOT Return OUR Surplus
Representative Fitzgerald stated in May 2026 – upon voting NO to returning $1.8 billion of the state’s (our) surplus to the voters (us) - that in so doing Wisconsin would incur a $2.9 billion deficit – that was her claim.
“With this proposal [to return our surplus], our state is projected to face a $2.9 billion deficit by the end of the 2027-29 biennium. This is financially irresponsible, and I cannot support legislation that puts our state in such a challenging situation. This is bad for Wisconsin taxpayers and it puts future funding for education, healthcare, and other essential areas at risk.” 2
Look what has happened since her NO vote in returning $1.8 billions of budget surplus to taxpayers? According to a report released by the State Controller's Office: 3
“The General Fund has an undesignated balance of $3.307 billion [this is the “surplus”] as of the end of the fiscal year [ended June 30, 2026]. General purpose revenue taxes were $23.132 billion compared to $22.363 billion in the prior year, an increase of $769 million or 3.4 percent [we realized MORE state revenue than expected]. General purpose revenue expenditures, excluding fund transfers, were $22.302 billion. This is $150 million less than the budgeted expenditure allocation of $22.452 billion” [we spent LESS than expected].
The positive balance exceeded budgeted estimates by about $350 million. The report further cited a $2.1 billion balance in the state's "rainy day fund" - the largest in the fund's history. According to the report, state tax collections were 3.4% higher than in 2025 and 2.2% higher than initially expected. The 2026 fiscal year ended July 30.
I earlier expressed the idea of being “consistent,” which pertains here. Representative Fitzgerald voted NO on returning surplus to you, the taxpayers, stating on May 14, 2026 that,
“With this proposal, our state is projected to face a $2.9 billion deficit by the end of the 2027-29 biennium. This is financially irresponsible, and I cannot support legislation that puts our state in such a challenging situation.”
Yet in a statement made publicly during a Candidate Forum on October 14, 2026, Representative Fitzgerald stated, “We do have a budget surplus; I would support using some of that budget surplus to fill in [municipal funding} gaps...” (time marker 1:29:38).
Memo to my State Representative: Why do “support using some of that budget surplus” now (our money), but back in May, such a “using” of surplus was “financially irresponsible”?
Wisconsin’s state surplus is now $3 billion – hardly the deficit Representative Fitzgerald claimed would result, even if the proposed $1.8 billion would have been refunded to us by virtue of legislation she voted against in May.
It appears that Representative Fitzgerald agreed to an assumption with state budget data tantamount to “cash” accounting rather than “accrual accounting.” For those of us who know financial accounting, what this means is that Representative Fitzgerald’s deficit forecast appeared to entirely ignore future tax revenues which turned out to be more than projected, and disregarded the possibility of Wisconsin’s economic growth.
Thanks, Joan!
2 May 14, 2026. News release: Rep. Fitzgerald Responds to Assembly Floor Session on Surplus Spending Bill.
3 October 15, 2026. Executive Budget and Finance, State Controller’s Office. FY26 Annual Fiscal Report – Budgetary Basis.
4 “In 2026, Wisconsin's GDP reached $361.4b, representing an increase of 1.5% from 2025. Wisconsin's GDP has grown at an annualized rate of 1.3% over the five years to 2026. Moreover, Wisconsin's trailing five-year GDP growth ranks it 41st out of all 50 US states.” Source: https://www.ibisworld.com/united-states/economic-profiles/wisconsin/#:~:text=Wisconsin's%20GDP%20has%20grown%20at,of%20all%2050%20US%20states
Conclusion
I am pro-business. I strongly support and will provide leadership toward a market economy, private property and related rights, private distribution of goods and services (cut the regulation imposed on business!), and private retention of business profits (cut the taxes and fees imposed on business!).
I support grassroots entrepreneurial activism (let’s create an abundance of free and private enterprises). I strongly support self-reliance and provisioning, personal effort and productivity, individual capability, ethical conduct and self-government, personal liberty and opportunity, and limited government.
Memo to my colleagues in Wisconsin state government: Create and maximize an environment where our grassroots entrepreneurs are enabled and empowered to create and develop their business ideas – and then get the hell out of the way!
As to Representative Fitzgerald’s legislative voting record – why she voted in any certain way on any legislation in her first term of office – only she can and must defend her own legislative voting record. It is, nonetheless, vitally important for our Assembly District 46 voters to know about Representative Fitzgerald’s record on key legislation related to small business as summarized above, directly relevant to business owners, employees, and their families.
View detailed information about Representative Fitzgerald’s legislative record, and the entire Wisconsin State Legislature.
See my qualifications and viewpoints on Wisconsin public policy.
For We The People,
JMD
